Supreme Court's Selective Nationalism Should Stop Right Now - ED | The Youth Blog | ED | The Youth Blog Supreme Court's Selective Nationalism Should Stop Right Now - ED | The Youth Blog
  • Check out our new reading mode

    Supreme Court’s Selective Nationalism Should Stop Right Now

    By

    February 15, 2017

    By Mohammad Safwan

    Notably, the SC had earlier ruled that all cinemas across the country HAVE TO play the national anthem before the beginning of a movie or a documentary and audience must stand to show their respect.

    Today, SC says that it is not mandatory to stand up for national anthems played during movies or documentaries. So subtle in being liberal that we almost failed to recognize this!

    The reason behind the verdict

    The reason behind modification of the earlier rule is the assault on a 59-year-old man at a theatre in Mumbai for not standing up when the anthem was being played on screen in movie ‘Dangal’.

    The earlier verdict of the court has caused various attacks on individuals who are disabled or were hearing impaired.

    In Tuesday’s verdict, however, the court clarified that people with a disability should be at their maximum alertness.

    National Anthem and it's compulsion

    Yeah, sure. Even if you are physically unable to do so.

    MY VERDICT

    Our nationalism seems to be quite selective.The modification in recent judgement shows double standards of the SC.

    The Supreme Court of the country clearly adjusted and changed its judgement due to the assault to pacify some who oppose the forced patriotism.

    I think the SC in one way or another trying to prove that it supports its decision while not holding completely to it. Perhaps our nationalism wakes up only when there are no controversies to be bothered with.

    Had nobody been abused like the case in Mumbai, people would still have been comfortable with it.

    Moving onto Dangal, there’s a scene where the national anthem is played. At that time in the theatre, I was shocked as I saw people shedding tears and rising when the national anthem was played.

    That’s something I call true spirit of patriotism which comes instinctively, not after being forced. And then there were others who were just not comfortable with people not standing up for the anthem just because it was played in a movie.

    Selective nationalism is as bad as forced nationalism. By doing this, the SC has done nothing towards moving in a space where everyone has the freedom to express his/her nationalism in their own way.

    True that.


    Other Recommendations:

    Supreme Court’s Judgement On Mixing Religion With Politics: Will It Be Effective?


    Winternship Partners:
    Love Matters India is an online platform that provides blush-free information and news about sexuality and sexual health for 18 to 30-year-olds in India. They are the first bilingual (English and Hindi) sexual health website in India with open, honest and non-judgmental attitude towards all topics related to love, sex, relationships and everything in between. Don’t forget to follow them on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and YouTube.
    SheThePeople is a video story telling space that inspires women, strengthens their efforts, exchanges leadership ideas, fosters networking and reinforces their ability to contribute to growth. Through their special videos on SheThePeople.TV they are presenting the modern Indian woman a platform to discuss and share the challenges faced by this up-tapped leadership community. Don’t forget to follow them on Facebook and Twitter.
    Twitter brings you closer to what you care about. Get on an exclusive chat with Twitter’s Aneesh Madani through ED. Follow him @aneeshmadani.
    The Harvard US India Initiative aims to empower the youth and promote awareness about India’s most pressing issues. Don’t forget to follow them on Facebook. 
    Social Samosa is the only online publication reporting trends, insights and breaking stories on social media marketing.

    Views presented in the article are those of the author and not of ED.

    Liked reading this article? Subscribe to us.
    In General